As Donald Richie pointed out, Ozu’s film An Adult’s Picture Book – I Was Born, But…
(Usually referred to as “I Was Born, But…) was “built around the social use of
power.” This power was divided among the adults in the film as well as the
young boys. For the young boys, the power came from age, brains, and/or brawn;
whereas in the society adults live in, which have not changed much from the 1930s,
power came from one’s social status in society (Richie 224).
Within the film, the young boy who held the power
within the group, or “gang” as Richie had called them, was able to act out a killing
of the other boys. This act of killing one another would start with a finger
gun, shot down the other child, and ended with a graveyard ceremony. Richie
even went as far as saying that this act was a parody of Christianity; however,
there is not enough evidence that was proven to prove such a claim (225). Perhaps
it was the motion of creating a cross among the head to body that lead Richie
to believe this?
Below I will provide a shot-by-shot analysis of the
first time the Yoshii boys had encountered and fought with the gang of young
boys. All the shots below are taken from a lowered camera, as if it were to
give us the children’s perspective (227).
Shot one: A full, two-shot of Yoshii Ryoichi and
Keiji; Ryoichi is at the center of the screen. They are walking on what seems
to be a dirt road and passing houses in the background. Light piano music could
be heard. The shorter boy (Keiji) points over to something that is off screen.
Ryoichi has his head turned towards the direction Keiji pointed over to. Keiji
then wiped off both eyes, indicating that he was crying. He wiped with the right
hand first then left hand. As Keiji was wiping off the tears, Ryoichi has his
head turned slightly towards Keiji, but still looking towards the area Keiji
pointed to earlier
Shot Two: At first, only six boys can be seen. It
appears to be a long shot. The piano music from shot one continues. One boy is
standing off to the side watching the other boys with this back turned away
from the camera; he seems to be shorter than the other boys as well. He also has
a sign on the back of his shirt, though in this particular scene, it cannot be
read. To the left of him are two boys wrestling with one another. They seem
almost equal in height; though it appears that one may be slightly taller than
the other. The two wrestling are a couple feet away from the smaller boy.
Between these three boys, almost in the center of the screen, are three more
boys. There are two others lying on the grass in front of the small boy with
the sign. Above them is a bigger boy (Kamekichi) standing over them; his legs
are in a wide stance. He is looking down upon the two on the ground. The camera
had used the tracking shot movement to reveal two other boys playing with
Kamekichi. As Kamekichi points to each of the fallen boys, they stand back up.
Shot three: Another full , two-shot. The camera
returns back to the Yoshii boys. They are standing close to each other. They
are watching on as the other boys/the gang continues whatever they were doing.
Shot four: Camera went back to the gang. The angle
is now different than before; however, it is still a long shot. The boys, who
were lying down, are now standing up on the left most side of the screen while
the wrestling boys are diagonal to the small boy wearing the sign. The
wrestling boys are still wrestling whereas the other group in the gang is surrounding
Kamekichi, who is now on the ground. With his hands in his pockets, Ryoichi
entered the shot towards the space between the boys; Keiji follows Ryoichi into
the shot in a similar fashion. Ryoichi walked up to the small boy with the sign
and pushes his head. The small boy walks away from Ryoichi and Keiji, who is
still keeping a slight distance, while rubbing his head. The other boys did not
notice this occurrence.
Shot five: a full, two-shot of Ryoichi and Keiji.
Keiji closed the distance between him and Ryoichi by stepping forward. He then
points to something off screen and sticks his hand back into his pocket.
Shot six: Cut to the two wrestling boys. It is a
full shot. They stop playing and look at Ryoichi and Keiji, who are now off
screen. The other boys in the background still have not noticed.
Shot seven: Two-shot, median shot of the Yoshii
boys. Ryoichi tapped Keiji on the chest with his hand while speaking to the two
wrestlers. “Who made my brother cry?”
Shot eight: Another full shot; this one is closer to
the boys than the previous ones. The two wrestlers turn their backs on the
Yoshii’s and hurried to the rest of the members. They stand around in a circle
until Kamekichi stands up. He then pushes the wrestlers out of his way while
the rest look on. He is much taller than the rest of the members. The music
changed lightly to indicate a change in mood; it sounds more alarming.
Shot nine: Two-shot, full shot of the Yoshii’s. Ryoichi
stays in his spot while Keiji cowers behind him. After what happened between
Keiji and Kamekichi, Keiji is still scared of him. (The height could also help
in this case).
Shot ten: Median shot of Kamekichi and four other
members behind him. He is standing with a slightly curved back. This seems
almost more “gangster-like” due to his manner.
Shot eleven: Median, two-shot of Yoshii’s. The same
as shot nine.
Shot twelve: Master shot! Keiji is still behind
Ryoichi whereas the gang is almost completely lined up in two rows, except for
the small sign boy standing close to them. The emerging city could be seen in
the background. Most of them take a step forward and wait for Kamekichi to move
before moving anymore. Kamekichi takes multiple steps to stand a few feet
apart. Shortly after, the rest of his gang joined him.
Shot thirteen: A full shot of all the boys. The
distance between them all got relatively smaller. Kamekichi grabbed Ryoichi’s hat’s
rim and moved it. Ryoichi gave no reaction.
Shot fourteen: A Three-Quarter shot of the gang.
Only four out of the eight boys can be clearly seen. Kamekichi and the well-dressed
boy (Taro) are in front.
Shot fifteen: Three-Quarter shot, two-shot of the
Yoshii’s. Keiji is holding onto Ryoichi’s shoulder; he looks disheartened.
Ryoichi is still standing with his hands in his pockets with his body turned to
an angle towards Keiji. He turned his head in the direction of the gang.
Shot sixteen: Three-Quarter shot of the six boys of
the gang. Taro tapped Kamekichi on the stomach while saying something to him. Kamekichi
nodded and looked at the ones standing to his left, who also nod. He then takes
another step forward.
Shot seventeen: Full shot of Kamekichi and Ryoichi staring
at each other while Keiji is bent over taking off his geta (wooden sandals).
Kamekichi asked Ryoichi, “Where did you move here from?” To which Ryoichi
responded, “Azabu.” Kamekichi looked Ryoichi up and down before imitating a gun
with his fingers.
Shot eighteen: Close-up to Median shot of Kamekichi.
He repeats the same gun motion, but has a confused look upon his face as he tilts
his head to the side.
Shot nineteen: Median, two-shot of Yoshii boys. They
look at each other than back to Kamekichi and his gang.
Shot twenty: Close-up to Median shot of Kamekichi.
He still has his fingers in the gun position and shakes them at the Yoshii’s.
He then fixed his hat and turned his attention back to the gang members.
Shot twenty-one: Full, master shot of the boys; they
are in a half-circle formation. Kamekichi nods at one of the members who then
stepped forward towards him. Kamekichi repeated the gun motion once again, to
which the member fell down on the ground. Kamekichi proceeded to make the cross
with his hands while the light piano music played. He commanded the fallen boy
to stand up again by placing his hand out. The boy does what he is told to be
shot down again. Kamekichi then ignores the boy on the ground while he turned
his attention back onto the Yoshii’s. He then attempts to shoot down Ryoichi,
but Ryoichi does not fall down. Kamekichi does the motion twice and tilts his
head to the side both times after Ryoichi does not comply. Kamekichi is mad
that Ryoichi would not play along so he hits Ryoichi’s hat.
Shot twenty-two: Three-Quarter shot of Kamekichi, Ryoichi,
and Keiji. They are standing in a diagonal row by height; Kamekichi’s head is
touching the top of the screen, proving his height. He attempts to shoot
Ryoichi once more before shoving him. Ryoichi responded by shoving Kamekichi
back. To which leads them to wrestle with one another. Keiji turns his back to the
camera and begins to run away from the fighting.
Shot twenty-three: A full, long shot of Keiji. He is
barefoot in the grass at a safer distance from the fight. He turns his head
back at his brother and the gang.
Shot twenty-four: long shot of the fight and gang.
One boy, on the left side of the screen is sitting down while the others are
standing while watching Ryoichi and Kamekichi fight.
Shot twenty-five: Cut back to a full shot of Keiji. He
just stares at the fight as well. He then turns his body towards the camera and
begins to scratch his genitals. The music changes to a quicker pace and more
comical sounding while he looks off-screen.
Shot twenty-six: Long shot of Mr. Yoshii walking
along the path. He is looking down and wiping off his pants leg. He is wearing
a suit.
Shot twenty-seven: Cut back to Keiji; it is the same
as Shot twenty-five. He is looking at the fight then switching back to their
father. He shouts something to Ryoichi.
Shot twenty-eight: Full shot of the boys fighting.
While Kamekichi and Ryoichi are going back and forth, the gang members are
cheering them (most likely Kamekichi) on.
Shot twenty-nine: Full shot of Keiji, same as shot
twenty-five and twenty-seven. He is looking at the fighting then quickly looks
over at his father. He bends down to pick up his shoes and runs towards the
camera.
Shot thirty: Long shot of the fighting boys and the
gang. Keiji enters the shot at screen right and taps Ryoichi. Ryoichi stop momentarily
to see what Keiji wants; Keiji at the same time has his body turned facing the
camera with his mouth opened. He then runs off screen. Ryoichi also attempts to
run off-screen; however after trying to get the last hit in, Kamekichi pulls
Ryoichi back to him. Ryoichi struggles a bit before he breaks free. He runs
after Keiji, going off screen, with Kamekichi running off screen behind him. The
gang members are still cheering them on.
Shot thirty-one: A long shot of Mr. Yoshii. He is
still walking on the path, but there is tall grass surrounding the path, making
it harder to see. Keiji, Ryoichi, and Kamekichi appear on the left-most side of
the screen. They run to the father’s general position as he is walking; Mr.
Yoshii does not notice them at first. Kamekichi runs straight whereas the
Yoshii boys curved to go to their father.
Shot thirty-two: Full shot of Kamekichi watching the
Yoshii’s. He looks annoyed at the boys as he stands still watching them.
Shot thirty-three: Cut to the young Yoshii’s. It is
a long shot. They stop running and turn their attention to Kamekichi.
Shot thirty-four: The same as shot thirty-two,
however, this time he hook punched the air before saying, “I’ll give it to you
good at school.” He continues to imitate a hook punch one more time before wiping
his mouth while staring at the boys, appearing to be tough.
Shot thirty-five: Median, two-shot of Ryoichi and
Keiji. They look at each other then back to Kamekichi.
Shot thirty-six: Kamekichi is seen in a full shot;
his stance is wide legged and hook punched the air once again. This makes him
seem bigger than he is as well as tougher.
Shot thirty-seven: A full, two-shot of the Yoshii
boys. They are looking at one another then back at Kamekichi. They slowly step
to the side. Ryoichi turns his back at Kamekichi (off-screen) and tilts his
hat. At the same time, Keiji stand facing Kamekichi and poses with his left leg
in the air and arms stretched out in a diagonal while making a face, mouth
gapped open to the side. When Keiji notices Ryoichi went off without him, he
puts his foot down which matched the last key in the tune. They both ran off-screen
to the left.
Although this section of a scene was a little over
two minutes long, there were a total of thirty-seven shots. Within this one
scene alone, we are able to see who among the young boys held power within the
gang at that moment: Kamekichi was the brawn of the group and Taro was the
brains. This was presented by Kamekichi being able to shoot down the other boys
and command them on when they could stand up again. Taro is seen as the brains
of this group by how Kamekichi, the same one who shot down Taro earlier, was
now looking at Taro on what action he should take, as seen in shot sixteen.
This scene is interesting to think about because it
is the first scene in which all the young boys are presented together. Before
Kamekichi tried to make Ryoichi and Keiji fall down like the other boys and was
rejected, he asked the two where they came from. Once he found out, he included
them in the ritual as if people from Azabu would know how to play. However, the
look on the three faces (Kamekichi, Ryoichi, and Keiji) indicates that they
might not have known what to do. That is when Kamekichi calls out another
member to demonstrate the ritual with him so Ryoichi and Keiji would
understand. This is first time the viewer sees this ritual as well. This ritual
is important to the boys because it shows who holds the power within the group.
The Yoshii boys were able to “outfight” Taro and Kamekichi later on and gain
the power to punish the disobeying members as a result of it (224).











YAY I GET TO COMMENT ON KELLY'S BLOG!!!! I love the scene that you used from I Was Born, But... In the beginning of your scene analysis you discussed "the power within the group", this was something that was well represented through your screen shots as well. For example, in shot thirteen when the "gang" of boys were approaching the two brothers. In this shot the much larger boy took a step and the other members of this "gang" followed closely behind him. I would also like to mention that I agree with the fact that social power was if not the main part but a major part of this movie.
ReplyDeleteI thought the introduction you did at before the analysis was very informative and gave an idea into the social order that is present in the group of kids. I was surprised at how many shots made up this scene but you did a good job in breaking it up and analyzing it. I think that your interpretation of the different formations that the bullies and the brothers make is helpful in understanding the social structure as well. One thing I would have like to see (I didn't do this in my own analysis either) would have been more analysis of how the soundtrack played a part in the scene and what it added to the shot. Overall it was a good analysis of one of my favorite scenes in the film.
ReplyDelete